The median first-time buyer in 2024 was 38 years old, with a down payment that took longer to accumulate than any prior generation had needed. By 2025, that median had risen to 40, a record, and the first-time buyer’s share of all transactions had dropped to 21 percent, the lowest point in more than four decades of NAR tracking. The first-time buyer’s market share has not been this thin since NAR began collecting the data in 1981. The 40-year median age is ten years older than the median in 2010.
They’re carrying student debt, car loans, and in many cases childcare costs that delayed their entry for years. The homes they can afford are older than ever: the typical U.S. home purchased in 2024 was 36 years old, up from 27 years in 2012, because the decade after the financial crisis produced fewer new homes than any ten-year period since the 1940s. Those two conditions together describe a buyer who’s acutely aware of post-purchase cost risk and who carries exactly the profile that home warranty companies like Choice Home Warranty are designed to serve.
That buyer is walking through listing doors in a market the August 2024 NAR settlement reshaped.
What the NAR Settlement Changed for Sellers
The rules that took effect August 17, 2024 removed offers of buyer-agent compensation from MLS listings and required written compensation agreements before property tours. Buyer-agent commissions have held largely steady: Redfin data puts the average at 2.40 percent in Q1 2025, compared to 2.36 percent when the rules launched. Nearly half of sellers, 45.9 percent, did not attempt to negotiate commissions at all. Most chose to keep offering compensation in the 2.5 to 3 percent range.
Sellers and agents entered a period where every component of a transaction required deliberate justification. Commission levels held; the conversation around them became more explicit. With each line item now subject to written agreement rather than inherited convention, agents started examining the full contents of a listing package. Sellers are asking what total value the listing delivers to the buyer, alongside the commission question.
That shift opened space for a category that had long operated at the edges of the transaction. Home warranties, typically treated as a last-minute closing concession, are now entering the listing preparation conversation earlier.
The Buyer Who Needs This Coverage
The 2024 NAR Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers showed first-time buyers carrying a 9 percent median down payment, the highest since 1997. Ninety-one percent of first-time buyers that year financed their purchase. For most, the down payment was the product of years of disciplined saving against student debt and high rent, both cited consistently as the primary obstacles to building adequate reserves.
By 2025, the profile had sharpened further. NAR’s latest data shows a bifurcated market: repeat buyers with substantial equity making all-cash offers at record rates on one side, first-time entrants who finally reached the purchase threshold at 40 on the other. Eighty-eight percent of buyers in that survey worked with a real estate agent. Agents are the primary channel through which coverage decisions get communicated before any offer is written.
The home these buyers are most likely to purchase is a 36-year-old property in a price range where new construction is not competitive. The gap between new and existing home prices has narrowed sharply: new homes commanded a 31.6 percent premium over existing inventory in 2024, down from 77.9 percent in 2012. First-time buyers priced out of new construction are purchasing older stock, and agents working those transactions understand the risk profile.
HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical panels, and water heaters are all working toward the end of their design life in a house that age. Any one of those failures generates a repair bill in the thousands of dollars with no prior warning. For a buyer who arrived at closing with reserves already depleted by the down payment, that exposure isn’t abstract. High interest rates through 2024 and into 2025 kept overall transaction volume lower than historical norms. Activity concentrated among buyers with compelling reasons to move forward despite financing costs. Those buyers were purchasing on thin margins, with little room for the unexpected once monthly obligations were locked in. Choice Home Warranty has calibrated its residential products for precisely that buyer profile.
How Agents Are Using the Warranty Earlier
The warranty conversation has moved up the timeline. Agents who previously offered home warranties as a closing concession are now incorporating them into the initial listing preparation meeting, particularly for older homes in price ranges where first-time buyers are active.
The listings where agents report the most traction are predictable: older single-family homes where deferred maintenance is common and buyers are overwhelmingly financing their purchase. These are also the listings where inspection reports tend to generate the most negotiation friction. Warranty documentation, presented before the inspection rather than after, changes how buyers approach that stage.
The timing of that recommendation affects deal quality. A buyer who sees warranty coverage documented in the listing starts with a different risk profile than a buyer who encounters an aging HVAC at inspection and builds contingency requests around it. For the seller, the difference can mean fewer renegotiation sessions after inspection and a cleaner path to close.
In markets where comparable inventory is limited, warranty inclusion is also a direct differentiator on the listing sheet. When two homes at similar price points have comparable ages and conditions, the one with documented coverage for major systems occupies a stronger position in a risk-averse buyer’s evaluation.
Transaction Outcomes for Warranty-Listed Homes
A study published in the Journal of Housing Research examining warranty inclusion in real estate transactions found a consistent relationship: homes offered with a warranty in place sold at a price premium and spent fewer days on the market than comparable listings without one. The effect was strongest for older, lower-priced homes, the category that defines most of the inventory today’s first-time buyers can access.
According to a Gallup poll cited in CHW’s professional resources, eight out of ten buyers report a preference for purchasing a home with coverage already in place. The translation of that preference into transaction outcomes depends on the buyer, the market, and the property. For listings that combine age, deferred maintenance history, and buyers with limited post-close reserves, the translation tends to be direct.
Choice Home Warranty in the Transaction Market
Choice Home Warranty is a home warranty company founded in 2008 with a mission to make home ownership simple and affordable. The company employs more than 700 people. CHW lead the industry by distributing coverage plans directly to consumer through two primary plan options — Basic and Total — with optional add-on coverage for pools, septic systems, and well pumps. Customers can file claims 24/7 with a simple click or call.
For real estate professionals, CHW operates a dedicated agent channel through chwpro.com, with a realtor-specific portal at realtor.choicehomewarranty.com. The portal gives listing agents and buyer’s agents access to coverage options, program materials, and policy documentation to include in the listing package. CHW built that channel to serve the transaction context directly. The moment of the sale is a distinct market with distinct needs.
Agents who recommend CHW to clients are relying on the company’s operational scale. CHW handles approximately 1.3 to 1.4 million service calls per year through a highly automated platform that matches qualified technicians to claims in real time. Choice Home Warranty has earned more than 100,000 five-star reviews across platforms including BestCompany, ConsumerAffairs, and Trustpilot. CHW has acquired Home Warranty of America and the Home Service Club; both acquisitions extended its contractor network and geographic reach.
Listing agents incorporating warranty coverage into seller packages use it to address buyer anxiety about post-purchase repair costs, reduce the risk of post-closing disputes over system or appliance failures, and support the asking price on properties where the age of major systems would otherwise drive buyer hesitation.
The Market Conditions Behind the Trend
A year after the settlement, commission rates have held and most sellers are still paying buyer-agent compensation. Transaction behavior has been largely stable. The more durable change was in how agents and sellers approached listing value: each component of the package came under explicit scrutiny because the new rules built that scrutiny into the process.
Warranties, which had functioned as an afterthought in seller strategy, moved to a more deliberate position in that conversation because the buyers showing up are the ones for whom coverage carries the most weight. The data from NAR’s two most recent profiles shows the direction: first-time buyer median age moved from 38 in 2024 to 40 in 2025; market share dropped from 24 percent to 21 percent. Each shift is incremental in isolation. Together, they describe a first-time buyer pool that is getting older, more financially stretched, and more concentrated in the older housing inventory. That’s the buyer who responds most directly to warranty coverage in a listing.
CHW built its professional program for the transaction context, and the past year has deepened the relevance of that positioning. Sellers who want to close the cautious, financially constrained buyer entering today’s market have a direct tool available. The warranty goes in the listing.
→ For deeper coverage, head to our full archive.


